Published: October 19th 2009
Source: Financial Post
Printer friendly version
Despite some positive signs that the economy is on the mend, it
could be years before Canadian railways fully recover from the
Rail shipments are an important bellwether for the broader economy
because they are so closely linked to global trade. As the economy
begins to show signs of life, so too have the volumes of North
American top-tier rails heading their into this earnings season.
In recent weeks, year-over-year volume declines have eased from the
single-digit to the mid-teen range from the 20% — or greater —
declines experienced earlier this year. “The industry is poised to
enjoy a healthy tailwind alongside a gradual improvement in the
North American and global economies,” Steve Hansen, Raymond James
analyst, said in a recent note.
Carloads at Canadian railways have steadily improved 15% since their
lows in May on the back of a strong harvest, the U.S. “cash for
clunkers” program, and a recent restocking, according to Jacob Bout,
CIBC World Markets analyst. Intermodal volumes, typically used for
shipping retail goods, also hit their 2009 peak level last week, he
Still, despite this positive momentum, carloads at Canadian National
Railway Co. were down 11.9% last week year over year, and Canadian
Pacific Railway Ltd.’s shipments fell 12.2%. While that is a sizable
improvement over the declines experienced in the second quarter, it
points to an underlying weakness in the economy, and suggests that
the volumes will slowly begin to return in 2010 and into 2011, Mr.
“The economic recovery may be a gradual one (versus a V-shaped
recovery),” he said in a recent note to clients.
This correlates with the commentary from CN, which will report its
third-quarter earnings today. Claude Mongeau, CN chief financial
officer, has said he expects it could take two or three years before
his railway sees the sort of traffic it had prior to the recession.
CP, which reports its results next Tuesday, has been even more
cautious. Fred Green, chief executive, says he doesn’t expect any
substantive growth until at least the back of 2010. He doesn’t
expect CP to see its typical “fall peak” this year as retailers
import fewer good for Christmas.
Container traffic at West Coast ports, where goods for retailers
come in from Asia, were down 20% last week, and retailers have
indicated they expect to import 10% less apparel and other consumer
goods this spring compared to last year, Mr. Bout said.
Moreover, CP’s volumes continue to be impacted by lower coal and
potash volumes, the latter is expected to remain sluggish through
Mr. Bout recently upgraded CN to “sector outperform” and increased
his price target to $64 a share, from $54 previously, on the
assumption that the worst is behind it.
He said he prefers it to CP because it is leaner and better
positioned to benefit from an economic recovery.