Derailment leaks toxic chemical into
July 3, 2008
Source: Globe and mail
Printer friendly version
toxic chemical is leaking from a derailed Canadian Pacific Railway car
into B.C.'s Thompson River, an Environment Ministry spokeswoman said
A local native leader predicted that the spill could have a
“devastating” impact on fisheries if it kills, contaminates or confuses
what's left of the river's salmon runs.
The car is one of four that derailed on Tuesday evening after a mudslide
near Lytton, B.C. The 100,000-litre cars were carrying ethylene glycol,
an ingredient in antifreeze, and one of the four is submerged in the
Thompson River and leaking the chemical into the water, said ministry
spokeswoman Kate Thompson.
“The information the divers had yesterday was the valves were sheared,
there were punctures, and when they put the knives in, there was liquid
coming out,” she said, adding that investigators are trying to determine
how fast the chemical is leaking and how best to get the cars out of the
“Anything that's submerged is going to be problematic. It's also
extremely fast-moving, dark, murky waters, so it's also a safety issue.”
But CP Rail says there's no evidence of a leak.
“Our mechanical specialists have told us that they believe, based on the
description from the diver at this time, the car isn't leaking,” Michael
LoVecchio said, adding that the company is testing the water near the
submerged car and hopes to have the results by the end of the Friday.
“Even if there had been a release, the officials have been very clear
they believe there would have been no impact on fisheries, no impact on
people,” he said.
But nearby communities and native fishermen fear the leak could deal
another blow to the river's salmon stocks.
Lytton First Nation Chief Byron Spinks said the band has taken its own
samples of the water and fish from the river and is sending them to be
“We're taking every precautionary measure to address the concerns of our
residents because the salmon is a major resource that we rely on for our
livelihood and we want to ensure ... the impact of the glycol in those
tanks will be minimized,” he said.
The band's fishing has been restricted due to declining levels of salmon
in the river. Now, Mr. Spinks fears the Department of Fisheries and
Oceans will close fisheries in the area if fish are found to be
contaminated with the chemical.
“That would have a devastating effect on our people,” he said. “We just
have only begun to start fishing, and if there's contamination right
now, that will prevent us from harvesting more fish.”
Ernie Crey, an adviser to the Sto:Lo Tribal Council, said if the
chemical enters the Fraser River, it could debilitate the scarce Early
Stuart sockeye salmon, whose numbers have dwindled to a predicted 39,000
this year from 200,000 a few years ago.
“That run of sockeye has been on the decline now for well over a decade,
and the Department of Fisheries and the aboriginal communities are
having to resort to heroic methods to try to preserve this run. … We
have this potential chemical spill at the very time they're entering the
river – the potential for wiping out this run is there.”
Craig Orr, who has a PhD in ecology and is director of the Watershed
Watch Society, said ethylene glycol is biodegradable and its toxicity to
aquatic organisms is low, especially once the chemical is diluted in the
river. But it could have other “sub-lethal effects,” such as hampering
salmon's ability to swim or to smell their way back to their spawning
“These fish are already fairly stressed – sockeye in particular,” he
said. “We just want to make sure we don't put additional stressors.”
What's more worrisome, Mr. Orr said, is that toxic spills from rail cars
continue to be a problem: In 2005, caustic soda from a Canadian National
Railway car spilled into the Cheakamus River north of Squamish, killing
more than 500,000 fish.
“It seems like it's a bit of a crapshoot what kind of chemical spills
next into a system,” he said. “Our streams are already hit so hard by
everything else. … There needs to be some sober second looks at how we
can prevent these things in the future.”